The Sciences at Black Mountain College, May 2021
David Peifer, Department of Mathematics, University of North Carolina at Asheville
https://www.blackmountaincollege.org/peifer-sciences/
Extract from section II: The Roots of the Sciences in the BMC Curriculum
'Rollins College, in Winter Park, Florida, began a progressive education experiment in 1925, when the college hired a new president. Within a year of starting at Rollins, President Hamilton Holt had implemented his “conference plan.” This approach emphasized one-on-one interaction between students and faculty. As opposed to lecturing, faculty served as mentors to guide students. Holt realized that this required a uniquely qualified professor. He began hiring his “golden personalities,” faculty distinguished in their discipline and dedicated to teaching, who could champion his new approach to liberal education. The four founding members of the BMC faculty were hired by Holt to teach at Rollins College during these years. By 1930, Holt had the whole Rollins campus community planning for an extensive reworking of the curriculum based on modern theories of progressive liberal education. To culminate this work, he held a national conference at Rollins in January 1931. Holt invited the philosopher John Dewey to chair the proceedings. The aim of the conference was to bring together leading experts on liberal education to envision a cohesive structure to the college curriculum in America. The conference, “The Curriculum for the Liberal Arts College,” resulted in an important report (Dewey 1931) that has served as a guide for many progressive liberal arts colleges since that time.
Frederick Raymond Georgia (1892-1961) was hired at Rollins as one of President Holt’s golden personalities. According to records at the Rollins College Archives, Georgia earned a bachelor’s degree in 1915 and his PhD in 1922 at Cornell University working in Chemistry. From 1915 until 1926, aside from serving 14 months in France as a First Lieutenant in World War I, he was a lecturer at Cornell University where he taught and published research in Sanitary Chemistry. In 1926, he joined the faculty at Rollins College as the head of Chemistry. A Rollins announcement stated that Georgia’s hire indicated President Holt’s intention “that science … is to receive proper emphasis in the liberal arts curriculum of Rollins College…” (Rollins 1926) In his position at Rollins, Georgia was given a leadership role in determining the college’s new curriculum. From 1930 until 1932, Georgia served as the chair of the college curriculum committee. This was an important position as the college was preparing to transform its academic program. The curriculum committee produced a preliminary report in 1930 and then the next year presented a comprehensive “plan for the organization of the curriculum of the College.” (Dewey 1931)
The 1931 Rollins College Curriculum Committee Report (Dewey 1931) outlined several ideas that would find their way into the BMC program. The curriculum was divided into a Lower and Upper Division. (At BMC these were called the Junior and Senior Divisions.) The Lower Division was intended to provide students with a “broad foundation,” while in the Upper Division students acquired “effective mastery of a field.” In the Lower Division, students were expected to gain competence and knowledge in several areas. This included: English, foreign language, mathematics, history, physics, chemistry, biology, sociology, and economics. In both divisions, the initiative was placed on the student and studies were determined by student interests. The report states that, “The Committee proposes to abolish the evaluation of the degree in terms of credits, grades and term of residence … To take the place of this system the Committee proposes to substitute two formal evaluations of the student’s work, one when he applies for transfer from the Lower to the Upper Division, and the other when he comes up for his degree.” (Dewey 1931)
Georgia played a key role at the conference, one of the seventeen members. These members included prominent administrators, faculty, and education experts from around the country. The members held several panel discussions which were open to the campus and public. Georgia organized and served as secretary for the conference. The final report, written by John Dewey, emphasized a curriculum meant to be directed by student interests, as well as, to expand and broaden these interests. It encouraged learning by experience. The conference report also clearly stated a disdain for grades. “Grades are not ends in themselves nor is the attainment of grades a worthy incentive for work in college. … If it is possible, and wherever possible, the consideration of grades should be eliminated as a method of appraisal of a student’s attainments.” (Dewey 1931) These ideas became centerpieces in the BMC curriculum.
In the next few years, as Rollins College began to implement these progressive ideas, some of the faculty on the curriculum committee began to question if President Holt’s conference plan should be abandoned. Holt took this as a personal attack, and not long after, he fired John Andrew Rice. Rice argued against his dismissal as an issue of freedom of speech. The case was brought to the attention of the American Association of University Professors (AAUP). At the hearing, Georgia and his colleague Ralph Lounsbury represented Rice. While the AAUP did eventually side with Rice and sanctioned Holt, this took too long and Rice was forced to leave Rollins. In the meantime, Holt also refused to renew contracts for Georgia and Lounsbury. One by one, Holt called several faculty members into his office to ask them to sign “loyalty” agreements if they wanted to stay at Rollins. In all, eight individuals were either fired or resigned from Rollins in 1933 because of the controversy with President Holt. (For an insightful perspective on these years at Rollins College see Jack Lane’s book “Rollins College: A Centennial History.” (Lane 2017)
During the summer of 1933, four of the former Rollins faculty (Georgia, Rice, Dreier, and Lounsbury), and several former Rollins students, decided to start their own version of a liberal arts college. Robert Wunsch, another fired Rollins faculty who would join BMC a year later, knew of property near Asheville that the new college could rent during the academic year. By the Fall 1933 semester, BMC had rented a large hall at the YMCA Blue Ridge Assembly near Black Mountain, North Carolina, and was open for business.
Because the AAUP was still considering Rice’s case, Georgia served as the first rector of BMC for one year until Rice took over. Georgia stayed at BMC for four years, teaching chemistry in what the BMC Preliminary Announcements described as meager laboratory settings. The Announcement stated, “Scientific apparatus and laboratory equipment will, of course, be on a simple scale. They will be sufficient, however, so that a small number of students may secure adequate training in laboratory work of undergraduate caliber in Physics, Chemistry, and Biology, ...” The Announcement goes on to point out the value to students of working in such a program. “Actually, in a pioneering enterprise, where the students may have to work to help fashion some of their own apparatus, much is gained that is usually lost where the latest, most expensive apparatus is found, ready for them to go ahead.” (BMC Records: General Files 1933-1956) After leaving BMC, Georgia went back to upstate New York and for several years was the Water Works Supervisor for the Filtration Plant at Cornell University.'