463 Valley Rd Caroline (as of 1957) 42 Depot Rd Caroline

Year built from Tompkins County Department of Assessment.

Address on 1950 census: Depot Rd, 2nd on right from bridge.  (bridge over creek on Beaver Creek Rd or lower bridge Brooktondale?)
1957 Caroline Street Directory: 42 Depot Rd, Arthur Volbrech. 
Address for Volbrecht: 463 Valley Rd (see wedding announcement for Lois J Volbrecht, Ithaca Journal, October 16, 1962, p4.)
Depot Rd became Valley Rd in 1957.