458 Valley Rd Caroline (as of 1957) 47 Depot Rd Caroline

Year built from Tompkins County Department of Assessment.

Address on census (sheet 75): Depot Rd, no house location. 
Address in  order of enumeration using the 1957 Caroline Street Directory: 47 Depot Rd.
Depot Rd renamed Valley Rd in 1957. 
Following numbering pattern of other houses that went from Depot to Valley Rd, this would be 458 Valley Rd.