Central School

Details
Name
Central School
Address
303 W Mill St Ithaca (as of 1899)
Year Built
1853
Demolished
1912
Building Type
Institution
Construction
not specified
Annotations
1866 Map of the City of Ithaca, Atlas of Tompkins County

S. H. No. 16 [School House Number 16]

1872 A. G. Bardin Map of Ithaca

School House

1898 Sanborn Fire Insurance Atlas of Ithaca

Central School House

1910 Sanborn Fire Insurance Atlas of Ithaca

Central Public School

Description
After the fire in 1912 destroyed this building, a new Central School building was constructed at the same location in 1923.
Media (Photos, Videos, Audio Recordings)

No media have been attached yet!

Add Source/NarrativeSources & Narratives
“In 1853 the present school house was erected on the corner of Mil and Albany streets, and the old house and site sold. The present building will accommodate about 1,000 pupils. There are three departments—primary, junior and senior. It is the object of the school to give to every person who will pursue the prescribed course of studies a good, thorough, English education, free of expense. The school, including text books, furniture and apparatus, is supplied by direct tax, after applying the apportionment from the common school fund and the gospel and school lot. The school, library consists of about 3,000 volumes of well selected works adapted to the wants of children and young people. 
A primary school for the convenience of pupils residing in the northern part of the village is maintained at Fall Creek in connection with the main school.”

Ithaca Journal Office, Ithaca, NY

Central School, 303 W Mill St

“That the disastrous fire, which destroyed the large, wooden Central School building at the southwest corner of Albany and Mill streets late yesterday afternoon was of incendiary origin, is the general belief of those who discovered the conflagration and the educational authorities, who reviewed the details of its start. Today, the historic structure, which was over half a century old, is a smouldering [sic] heap of debris, surrounded by charred and broken walls….
Constructed Many Years Ago.
The Central school building contained 13 rooms. It was built many years ago and hundreds, yes, thousands of Ithacans received their preliminary schooling within its walls. It was originally constructed as a six-room building, then two more rooms were added. Later more rooms were built on, and it was remodeled, repaired and rebuilt as its needs grew more imperative. The building has been afire several times before but none of the blazes, until yesterday, resulted disastrously….
While yesterday’s fire did not destroy the structure it reduced the interior to ruins, and would render the building in its old form an impossibility.”

“Parents Become Excited Over Safety of Children,” Ithaca Daily Journal, April 30, 1912, 6, accessed October 12, 2025, https://www.nyshistoricnewspapers.org/?a=d&d=idj19120430-01.1.6