Labelled "219 S Cayuga" on 1954 Roy Wenzlick & Co. tax assessment photos, but appears in 1954 and 1956 street directories as 217, Finney Service Center.
"The old former Godfrey foundry building on South Cayuga street which for a number of years has been removed and will be replaced by a gasoline filling station to be constructed by Pritchard and Banfield."
“Two Old Landmarks Being Removed for Modern Structures,” Ithaca Journal, June 3, 1924, 5.