"That portion of Brooktondale Rd (Rte. 330) from the lower bridge in Brooktondale to the intersection of the Boiceville (West Slaterville) Rd. will become Valley Rd." See "Easy St to Be No More," Ithaca Journal, October 17, 1957, 5.
The 1957 Street Directory places the address of the church at 540 Valley Rd and the address of Clayton Caveney at 546 Valley Rd. 546 Valley Rd was last listed as a residence in the Ithaca Journal in 1990 and first listed as the church's address in 1991.